2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Soroban Capital Partners LP v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue — Commentary

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Second Circuit: “Limited Partner” (I.R.C. § 1402(a)(13)) Means Limited Liability and No Managerial Control; NESE Is a TEFRA Partnership Item Reviewable in FPAA Proceedings 1. Introduction Case:...

Bergin v. N.Y. State Unified Court System: The Second Circuit Aligns Title VII Religious-Accommodation Prima Facie Proof with Abercrombie’s Motivating-Factor Standard

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Bergin v. N.Y. State Unified Court System: The Second Circuit Aligns Title VII Religious-Accommodation Prima Facie Proof with Abercrombie’s Motivating-Factor Standard 1. Introduction In Bergin v....

Second Circuit Adopts Hunt Test for Associational Standing Under § 1983 and Overrules Aguayo

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Second Circuit Adopts Hunt Test for Associational Standing Under § 1983 and Overrules Aguayo Case: Defending Education v. Croton-Harmon Union Free School District Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the...

Defensive Setoff Is Not a Bankruptcy “Claim”: No Proof of Claim Required to Preserve Purely Defensive Setoff Rights

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Defensive Setoff Is Not a Bankruptcy “Claim”: No Proof of Claim Required to Preserve Purely Defensive Setoff Rights 1. Introduction Case: In Re: SVB Fin. Grp. (2d Cir. Sept. 9, 2026). Parties: SVB...

Santos v. Blanche: CBP May Reopen/Reconsider Reinstatement Orders Under 8 C.F.R. § 103.5, and Denials Are Reviewable Under 8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(6)

Date: Sep 12, 2026

CBP May Reopen/Reconsider Reinstatement Orders Under 8 C.F.R. § 103.5, and Denials Are Reviewable Under 8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(6) I. Introduction Santos v. Blanche (2d Cir. Sept. 8, 2026) addresses two...

Monell Liability for Brady Violations Does Not Turn on Intent; “Forwarding” Limits Police Fair-Trial Fabrication Claims

Date: Sep 11, 2026

Monell Liability for Brady Violations Does Not Turn on Intent; “Forwarding” Limits Police Fair-Trial Fabrication Claims 1. Introduction Jimenez v. City of New York (2d Cir. Sept. 4, 2026) arises from...

TVPA Fee Awards: When a “Rare Case” Justifies Above-Forum Rates and Multi-Timekeeper Staffing

Date: Sep 11, 2026

TVPA Fee Awards: When a “Rare Case” Justifies Above-Forum Rates and Multi-Timekeeper Staffing I. Introduction Moore v. Rubin (2d Cir. Sept. 4, 2026) addresses a recurring, high-stakes question in...

Merger Doctrine at the Pleading Stage: Opinion-Based Price Lists Cannot Be Dismissed Without a Factual Record on Methodology and Numerical Range

Date: Sep 11, 2026

Merger Doctrine at the Pleading Stage: Opinion-Based Price Lists Cannot Be Dismissed Without a Factual Record on Methodology and Numerical Range 1. Introduction In Rapaport v. Nivoda (2d Cir. Sept....

§ 922(g)(1) Unanimity Rule: Jury Need Not Agree on the Specific Firearm or Ammunition Possessed

Date: Sep 10, 2026

§ 922(g)(1) Unanimity Rule: Jury Need Not Agree on the Specific Firearm or Ammunition Possessed Case: United States v. Miguel Rivera, A/K/A Macho (2d Cir. Sept. 3, 2026) Court: United States Court of...

Cabined Delegation Rule for Third-Party Risk Notifications in Supervised Release

Date: Sep 10, 2026

Cabined Delegation Rule for Third-Party Risk Notifications in Supervised Release: Courts May Authorize Probation to Identify At-Risk Third Parties When the Court Defines the Risk 1. Introduction In...

Second Circuit Adopts the “Maxwell Rule”: Appeals May Be Dismissed for Nonpayment of Sister-Circuit Rule 38 Sanctions in Related Matters

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Second Circuit Adopts the “Maxwell Rule”: Appeals May Be Dismissed for Nonpayment of Sister-Circuit Rule 38 Sanctions in Related Matters 1. Introduction Arrowhead Capital Finance, Ltd. v. Picture Pro...

Second Circuit Adopts a Multi-Factor Test for When Denial of Leave to Amend Precludes a Later Suit

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Second Circuit Adopts a Multi-Factor Test for When Denial of Leave to Amend Precludes a Later Suit 1. Introduction Trireme Energy Development v. RWE Renewables (2d Cir. Sept. 1, 2026) addresses a...

Federal Witness-Retaliation Conspiracy Under 18 U.S.C. § 1513(b) Is Categorically a CIMT; CIMT Ground Not Vague as Applied

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Federal Witness-Retaliation Conspiracy Under 18 U.S.C. § 1513(b) Is Categorically a CIMT; CIMT Ground Not Vague as Applied Case: Dziedziach v. Blanche (2d Cir. Aug. 31, 2026) Holding (core):...

Second Circuit: NFA Registration and (Former) $200 Tax Do Not “Meaningfully Constrain” Second Amendment Rights Under Bruen Step One

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Second Circuit: NFA Registration and (Former) $200 Tax Do Not “Meaningfully Constrain” Second Amendment Rights Under Bruen Step One United States v. DeFelice (2d Cir. Sept. 2, 2026) I. Introduction...

Second Circuit Rejects NLRB’s Tesla Presumption and “Narrow Tailoring” for Dress Codes; Requires Balanced Republic Aviation Analysis

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Second Circuit Rejects NLRB’s Tesla, Inc. Presumption and “Narrow Tailoring” for Dress Codes; Requires a Balanced Republic Aviation Analysis Case: Siren Retail Corp. v. NLRB (2d Cir. Sept. 2, 2026) |...

Indivisible-Conduct Disclaimers Cannot Defeat Federal-Officer Removal for PBMs in Opioid Public-Nuisance Litigation

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Indivisible-Conduct Disclaimers Cannot Defeat Federal-Officer Removal for PBMs in Opioid Public-Nuisance Litigation 1. Introduction In County of Westchester v. Express Scripts (2d Cir. Sept. 2,...

Public High School Classroom Displays Are Garcetti “Official-Duties” Speech (Government Speech) in the Second Circuit

Date: Sep 2, 2026

Public High School Classroom Displays Are Garcetti “Official-Duties” Speech (Government Speech) in the Second Circuit Case: Dolce v. Connetquot Cent. Sch. Dist. (2d Cir. Aug. 31, 2026) Court: United...

Revenue Rule Does Not Bar Foreign Tax Authority’s Fraud Suit to Recover Refund Payments Where No Tax Was Owed

Date: Sep 2, 2026

Revenue Rule Does Not Bar Foreign Tax Authority’s Fraud Suit to Recover Refund Payments Where No Tax Was Owed 1. Introduction Skatteforvaltningen v. Markowitz (2d Cir. Aug. 31, 2026) is a bellwether...

Second Circuit Adopts “Representative Sample” Pleading for Direct FCA Claims While Reviving Reverse FCA Liability for Concealed Overpayment Retention

Date: Sep 2, 2026

Second Circuit Adopts “Representative Sample” Pleading for Direct FCA Claims While Reviving Reverse FCA Liability for Concealed Overpayment Retention 1. Introduction In United States v. Amerisource...

Lowell v. Lyft, Inc.: ADA Plaintiffs Must Prove Proposed Modifications Will Likely Produce Effective WAV Service; “Facial Reasonableness” Alone Is Not Enough

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Lowell v. Lyft, Inc.: ADA Plaintiffs Must Prove Proposed Modifications Will Likely Produce Effective WAV Service; “Facial Reasonableness” Alone Is Not Enough 1. Introduction In Lowell v. Lyft, Inc....